5 Best Toasters for Bagels – Reviews (2023)

1. Cuisinart CPT-122 2-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster

This toaster is one of the best toasters for bagels in the market. Plastic has been used in its construction along with stainless steel, which brings many perks to the toaster; top of the list are corrosion resistance, fire resistance, and high strength. It is also quite easy to clean; if a stain or mark forms on the body, you can easily wipe it away with a damp cloth.

It has two slots, both 1 and a ½ inch wide. You can easily put both thick and thin toasts, bagels, and even pastries in it, and it will evenly heat them according to your taste. It also features a removable crumb tray at the bottom, which ensures easy disposal of crumbs that are collected in it.

Furthermore, it offers three functions, bagel, defrost and reheat. The bagel button on the toaster only warms the upper half of the bagel to make the upper half crunchy and keep the lower half of the bagel soft. If you do not prefer to have your bagel like this, then use the normal toast setting, which will warm it up evenly from both sides.

Moreover, the reheat button warms up your food without browning it any further. This model also has a shade control setting with 7 shades from lightest to darkest. You can control it easily with a knob; by moving the knob, you will get a bagel with customized shade. In addition to that, the easy-to-use design of this toaster adds extra stars to it. All you need to do is press the button, control the dial and push the lever.

If you love having bagels with your coffee in the morning, then invest your money in this model. It really is the best toaster for bagels due to its strong construction and the various options that it provides you. In short, you will be getting one of the best 2 slice bagel toasters at a minimal price.

2. Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast 2-Slice Smart Toaster

This Breville toaster oven for bagels is one of the finest models. It comes with a sleek and shiny body which alone is enough to convince people to purchase it. Firstly, the die-cast used in its construction gives sturdiness to its lustrous body. Along with that, it has many features that make having this toaster in your kitchen a staple. It powers up with just a push of a button and starts turning your cold bagel into a crispy, scrumptious treat.

It has 2 slots for bread and bagels that are wide enough to hold both bagels and bread. The strong grates in the slot hold the bagel and lower it to warm it up when the toaster is turned on. When the bagel is done, the grates bounce up and let you know your food is ready. No more pushing the lever up and down to toast your bagels. Other features include a ‘lift and look’ button that lets you check up on your food and a ‘bit more’ button that, when pressed, browns it for a few more seconds.

There is a slide bar on the lower side of the front. This bar moves from left to right and has the numbers from 1 to 5. These numbers indicate the shade of your bagel from light to dark, 1 being the lightest and 5 being the darkest shade. Adjust the knob to control the browning of your food. Furthermore, there is a removable crumb tray at the bottom that you can easily pull out to eliminate all the crumbs that fall out. Last but not the least, another handy feature is that there is a sound system installed in this model that makes a sound when your food is done.

If you are looking for a toaster that toasts evenly, look no further. Investing your money in this Breville toaster oven for bagels will be a very wise decision if you are a person who uses their toaster for bagels on a daily basis. With its sturdy body and advanced features, it will last you a couple of years, even after daily usage.

3. KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster

This toaster is one of the finest models the market offers. There are many reasons that make it the best two-slice toaster for bagels. First comes its stainless steel body that not only has corrosion and scratch-resistant qualities but is also able to withstand heat, unlike plastic. The silver sleek body makes it a perfect addition to your kitchen counter.

In addition to that, it comes with 4 slots for your bagels and bread; each slot is 1.5 inches wide. The slot width is enough to hold both thin and thick slices. It has a dual control system, one for each pair of slots. The control system includes 4 toaster functions and a shade setting with 6 shade options from 1 (lightest) to 6 (darkest).

There is a defrost option to defrost the bread before toasting, a reheat option to warm up your toast without browning it, and a bagel option to warm up the inside and make the outside of the bagel crunchy. The 6 shade options give you the freedom to choose how dark you want the shade of your bagel to be.

Other than these amazing and user-friendly features, it has a removable crumb tray at the bottom. As a result, this makes the disposal of crumbs and pieces less time-consuming and easier. The two push levers not only help in lowering the bagel inside to warm it up but also shove it out for easy retrieval of your food.

The sophisticated construction and the user-friendly features of this model are enough to convince a person to purchase it. In addition to that, the fact that it offers 4 bagels to be toasted simultaneously makes it perfect for you if you have a bigger family.

4. BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster

Black Decker is known for its outstanding craftsmanship, and this toaster is no different than the rest of their machines. It comes with a plastic body with accents of stainless steel added to it. The major plastic construction keeps the toaster light in weight, and the stainless steel accents bring corrosion and heat resistant qualities to its sturdy body. Most importantly, getting these qualities with a light price tag is like a cherry on top.

It comes with 2 wide slots at the top that are wide enough to carry even thicker bagels and slices of toast. The slots have a self-positioning system that adjusts the toast or bagel. The heat setting is perfect enough to evenly toast your bagels and give them a crunch on one side while keeping them soft on the other side. The push lever system is made of stainless steel, and it works like a dream. It takes your food inside the toasted and, once it is done, brings it outside without getting jammed.

It offers multiple functions, and it is easy for you to choose one; all you need to do is push one of the buttons present at the front. There is a defrost option, a bagel option, and a cancel button to immediately halt the toaster. It also offers 7 different shade options, from lightest to darkest. The lever also offers extra lift, so once your toast is made, you can push it a bit extra in an upward direction to easily take it out without burning your hands.

This toaster has sophisticated construction and offers great performance for an extremely low amount of money. If you are a student who is always on the go and is also on a budget, invest your money in this 4 slice bagel toaster to get evenly toasted bagels every morning.

5. KitchenAid KMT2116ER 2 Slice Slot Toaster

This model of toaster comes loaded with features that are bound to make your life easier. Firstly, it has a glossy yet robust body that will not only amp up your kitchen but will also add extra years to the life of this handy piece of machinery. It comes in a variety of colors that you can choose from. The user-friendly design adds more stars to this model.

It comes with 2 slots that are not only 1.5 inches wide but also quite long, so you can easily put two pieces of a bagel in a single slot. The slots have stainless steel grates that keep it evenly warm for all areas so that your bagels get toasted perfectly from all sides. In addition to that, there is a high lift lever that helps in pushing the bagel upward to eliminate any burning accidents.

The automatic lowering system removes the hassle of lowering the bagels and toasts manually, and once they are done being toasted, it automatically pushes them up. It offers three functions that you can easily choose from, a reheat option, keep warm, and a bagel setting. The ‘keep warm’ setting will keep your bagel warm for 2- 3 minutes after toasting. Lastly, the 7 shade options let you customize the shade of your bagel according to your liking.

If you want to buy a toaster that will not only give you evenly toasted bagels but will also amp up your kitchen, then this is the perfect model. With its classy and sturdy body along with top-notch features, it will surely bring a lot of comfort to your life and beauty to your kitchen.

FAQs

Can you put bagels in the toaster?

Yes, you can use a toaster for your bagels.

What does the bagel button do?

The bagel button is specifically for toasting your bagels. The bagel setting sees to it that only one side gets toasted, and the other side remains soft.

What is the best toaster for bagels?

Cuisinart CPT-122 is the best toaster for bagels as it comes with wide slots and offers a separate bagel function.

Can you put a toaster oven under the cabinet?

Yes, you can put a toaster oven under the cabinet; consider the heat and ventilation before installing it.

Conclusion

Breakfast is one of the most important meals of the day. However, most people skip it as they are often in a hurry, or cooking food early in the morning seems like a very long and tedious job. Therefore, purchasing a toaster with a bagel function may save you from both starving yourself and spending time on cooking. Here are our top three recommendations if you are having a hard time picking a model for yourself.

1. Cuisinart CPT-122 2-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster has quite a sturdy construction along with an easy-to-use design.
2. BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster provides top-notch performance at a very low price.
3. KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster has extra slots and offers multiple functions.

I hope this article helped you pick the perfect model of the toaster for a bagel for yourself.

Recommended reading:

Toaster Oven Vs Microwave

How To Toast Bread In Toaster Oven?

Toaster Oven Vs Microwave

Best Toasters Made In USA

Toaster Vs Sandwich Maker

Toaster Ovens Vs Conventional Ovens